OUT-LAW NEWS

ICSID may offer member states economic value, study finds

Freight transportation - SEOSocialEditorial image

A credible framework for investment disputes may help encourage cross-border investment. shaunl/iStock


A new study highlights the potential “economic value” behind having a dedicated international framework to settle investor-state disputes, an expert has said.

International arbitration experts Sylvia Tonova and Johanne Brocas of Pinsent Masons were commenting as a new study found that membership of the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) was associated with a substantial increase in foreign direct investment (FDI).

This finding was published as part of a study examining the potential relationship between ICSID membership and FDI flows. On average, the study estimated that membership increased annual bilateral FDI flows by roughly US$640,000 per source-destination country pair, equivalent to about US$19 million in additional annual inflows per destination country when aggregated across the 29 largest FDI source countries.

Tonova said the headline finding was striking, but warned it did not necessarily mean that ICSID membership will produce a comparable increase in investment for an individual country.

Instead, she said the research shed new light on the economic merits of ICSID membership itself. “Earlier studies have largely examined whether investment treaties or investor-state dispute settlement more generally affect foreign investment,” she said. “This study seeks to isolate the effect of participation in the ICSID framework and finds that membership is associated with a substantial increase in bilateral FDI, independently of the proliferation of bilateral investment treaties (BITs).”

The paper showed these findings were “not driven by contemporaneous macroeconomic shocks, the signing of trade agreements, formation of customs unions, recovery from war or improvements in bureaucratic quality”. It also found no statistically significant investment response to a country’s first publicly known treaty-based ISDS dispute. The results, it said, were consistent with ICSID membership strengthening the credibility of host-country commitments to foreign investors.

Commenting on this point, Tonova said: “It is notable that the authors find no statistically significant reduction in investment following a country’s first publicly known treaty-based investor-state dispute. On this evidence, ICSID membership appears to support investment confidence, without a detectable fall in investment following the first dispute. That does not rule out more moderate effects. This avoids generalising to every use of ISDS or treating a statistically insignificant result as proof of no effect.”

At a time when governments are reconsidering the role of investor-state dispute settlement, she said the results support the idea that a credible international dispute resolution framework may itself contribute to investor confidence. “ICSID membership does not itself grant investors substantive protections or amount to consent to arbitration,” she said. “The finding that membership is nevertheless associated with increased foreign investment therefore raises an important point: the institutional framework for resolving and enforcing disputes may have economic significance in its own right.”

Brocas said: “For investors, the research highlights the importance of looking beyond a country’s signature of the ICSID Convention to whether membership has become legally effective. Investors also need to establish the basis for consent to arbitration and the protections available to their investment. That planning may be particularly important for long-term projects that depend on government licences, concessions or regulatory commitments.”

ICSID had just 20 contracting states when it was established in 1966 and this number has grown to 159 in 2026. ICSID is also expanding its presence worldwide. In August, it opened an office in Singapore – its first staffed office outside of Washington DC. In early November it opened its first European office in Paris.

That expansion provides a backdrop to the study’s findings on the investment benefits of ICSID membership, Tonova said: “As debate over the future of ISDS continues, the research strengthens the case for a credible international framework for resolving investment disputes, pointing to its potential to build investor confidence and encourage cross-border investment.”

We are processing your request. \n Thank you for your patience. An error occurred. This could be due to inactivity on the page - please try again.