OUT-LAW ANALYSIS

Digital Fairness Act: ‘addictive design’ and ‘dark patterns’ in the crosshairs

Buy it now button on smartphone_Digital - SEOSocialEditorial image

Rokas91/iStock.


Every business that sells ‘digital products’ to EU consumers would need to review, and potentially reconfigure, every part of their sales process to comply with proposed new measures outlined in the draft Digital Fairness Act (DFA).

A digital product is, in effect, any product or service made available online.

The DFA proposal represents the European Commission’s attempt to bring aspects of EU consumer law up to date for the digital age. Among other things, it takes aim at features that pull consumers towards engaging with businesses and the products and services they offer, raising questions all businesses will need to consider: which features are legitimate for maximising sales of products or services, which are addictive, and which cross the line as being deceptive, manipulative or distortive?

Below, we look at the theoretically extensive compliance exercise that could arise from the wording of a single article on ‘addictive design’ within the DFA proposal, as well as what practices the Commission hopes to eradicate with its proposals on ‘dark patterns’.

Giving consumers more control over ‘addictive’ features

Under Article 17 of the draft DFA, traders that design, organise or operate their digital products in a manner that is intended, or can reasonably be foreseen to encourage, compulsive or excessive use would be obliged to make effective tools easily accessible to consumers that allow them to disable features said to “encourage” such use.

Those features include:

  • features enabling automatic play of content and uninterrupted content consumption without effective and regular interruption moments that enable deliberation by the consumer on their willingness to consume more content;
  • ·notifications not triggered by, or not directly related to, the consumer’s interaction or activity on the service;
  • features incentivising engagement at regular times or with greater frequency, including through penalties or loss of benefits for failing to engage regularly or within specified time intervals;
  • features and system behaviours that encourage continued use by simulating interpersonal relations, such as persistent prompts to continue engaging with an automated system.

The scope of the provisions is broad. While the concept of a ‘digital product’ is not defined in the draft legislation, ‘product’ is – the term refers to “any good or service including immovable property, digital service and digital content, as well as rights and obligations”.

The list of features is non-exhaustive. The European Commission would have powers to add or modify the list under the proposed new legislation.

There are some limited exceptions to the scope of the Article 17 obligations. For example, in so far as certain online service or AI system providers are subject to similar addictive design requirements envisaged under the proposed new EU KIDS Act, Article 17 of the DFA would not apply “for practices concerning minors”. Services and systems primarily designed for educational purposes and operated by educational institutions, as well as those specifically developed and operated for the sole purpose of scientific research and development, would also be exempt.

The purpose of Article 17 can be gleaned from a non-binding recital contained in the DFA proposal. It states: “Digital products are increasingly designed not merely to serve the purposes for which consumers use them, but to capture and retain consumers' attention, thereby encouraging prolonged engagement which may translate into harm of consumers’ economic interests. Certain design features and functionalities exploit consumers' cognitive, psychological and other vulnerabilities for economic purposes.”

The potentially extensive compliance requirements arising

It is important to stress what the Article 17 proposals would not do, if implemented as drafted. They would not ban measures that encourage compulsive or excessive use nor require businesses to turn off such features by default. Instead, the focus is on empowering consumers and giving them the means to disable addictive features.

The Article 17 requirements would, subject to the limited exceptions, impact every business that has a website or offers an app and apply to how those platforms are designed and how they operate in practice – essentially, to everything that might feed into or support the whole consumer experience. Hundreds of different processes might need to be rethought, not just for new digital products under development, but in terms of retrofitting the consumer experience in engaging with existing digital products made available. Various business functions would need to be involved, from product teams, to compliance, and operational teams.

Before businesses ponder what tools they might need to deploy for consumers to use, they would need to work backwards and consider some fundamentals across the whole digital product lifecycle. They would need to:

  • map all processes that concern the design, organisation and operation of their digital products;
  • consider how those processes are linked to consumer-facing features;
  • assess which of those features might be said to be intended to encourage compulsive or excessive use, or could otherwise be reasonably foreseen to have that effect;
  • undertake an impact assessment to determine whether the relevant features in-scope are genuinely compulsive or excessive;
  • make a judgment on which of the features need to be able to be disabled by consumers – and how to link use of consumer-facing tools for that purpose to changes in the way back-end systems or processes are configured or operate.

Businesses that rely on third-party technology as part of their process for making digital products available to consumers would need to consider the need to impose addictive design requirements in suppliers’ contracts. The proposals, if implemented, would place a greater emphasis on businesses understanding what the technology they source from others does and its effect on consumers.

What is unclear from the Commission’s proposals is whether businesses’ Article 17 obligations would continue to apply where they make their digital products available for consumers to buy via online marketplaces. It is not clear whether the online marketplace would be considered the ‘trader’ in that scenario, or whether the duties around addictive design would continue to apply to individual businesses that make use of such a marketplace for sales.

Businesses will want clarity on that point as the DFA moves through the legislative process.

A ban on dark patterns

Under the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA), online platforms are already banned from using dark patterns in the design and organisation of their online interfaces. However, the European Commission wants to go further, by banning their use by all businesses selling to consumers.

The term ‘dark patterns’ is not defined in the DFA proposal, but Article 10 and an accompanying annex provides clarity on the type of practices the Commission means to refer to and wishes to prohibit.

Under Article 10, traders would be banned from designing, organising or operating their online interfaces – software such as websites or apps, or parts thereof – in a manner that is likely to deceive or manipulate consumers, or in a manner that is likely to otherwise materially distort the economic behaviour of consumers.

To supplement this proposed general ban on using dark patterns, the Commission has listed 10 distinct practices, in an annex to the DFA, that it considers to constitute use of a dark pattern. These practices would be automatically prohibited if the proposal is implemented.

The list of automatically prohibited dark patterns – which the Commission would be empowered to add to or modify – refers to:

  • making false claims about the availability or the popularity of a product, or not clearly and unambiguously disclosing relevant qualifications about the availability or the popularity of that product;
  • persistently displaying statements throughout the ordering process about the availability or popularity of a product or promotional offer to create an impression of scarcity;
  • using default options which the consumer is required to reject or otherwise inferring the consent of the consumer to payment for an additional product, a different quantity of the product or a different product;
  • presenting the option to decline an invitation to purchase or to continue the supply of a product as the wrong choice;
  • creating the false impression that the consumer does not have any other option apart from the prominently featured option;
  • persistently requesting that consumers make a choice or change their choice where that choice has already been made, where this is not necessary for the trader to comply with legal requirements;
  • using misleading or ambiguous language in the presentation of choices to consumers, including by reversing the linguistic or framing logic within a list of choices, or using double negatives;
  • presenting the price or, where applicable, information about the duration of the contract and its automatic renewal, in an invitation to purchase with less prominence than other items of material information;
  • sending or displaying to the consumer notifications that falsely suggest that another consumer, the trader or a third party has contacted the consumer, or that a matter requires the consumer's attention;
  • making the steps required to refuse, withdraw or change a choice disproportionately more numerous, complex or time-consuming than is reasonably necessary.

There are, however, clues as to what other practices might constitute use of a dark pattern and be prohibited from recitals in the draft DFA.

One recital cites practices that “pressure, mislead or otherwise interfere with consumers’ ability to take free and informed transactional decisions”. Another references “exploitative design features that materially distort the economic behaviour of consumers by directing consumers to choices or actions that benefit the trader, but which may not be in the consumer’s interests, including, for example, by giving more prominence to choices that benefit the trader, decreasing the prominence of material information or forcing consumers to click through too many steps to access it, or making the choice indicated by the consumer lead to an unexpected result”.

The Commission has also given a specific example of practices in the ultra-fast-fashion online retail sector that “influence consumers’ choices towards impulsive buying and overconsumption”.

Further insight might also be gleaned from the approach of UK regulators towards ‘dark patterns’.

In its Online Choice Architecture (OCA) discussion paper (76-page / 149KB PDF) published in 2022, the UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) referred to dark patterns as “a set of (deliberately) manipulative practices identified by user experience (UX) designers” and referenced research that cited other practices such as “sneaking unasked-for items into shoppers’ baskets, greying out legitimate options so that users are less likely to click on them, and false popularity and scarcity claims”.

The CMA further implied that practices such as drip pricing and use of hidden fees and ranking could also be classed as use of a dark pattern. That would be to consider the concept to be broader than is arguably envisaged under the DFA proposal. However, drip pricing and hidden fees and unfair ranking practices would be illegal under the DFA, whether or not they are considered to constitute “dark patterns”.

Recent CMA consumer law enforcement cases have involved dark patterns, from pressure selling involving misleading countdown timers and pre-selected opt-in purchases, to drip pricing.

The CMA has also referred to subscription traps as another example of misleading online choice architecture, though not as a ‘dark pattern’ per se. Both the proposed DFA and the UK’s existing Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 contain rules tackling unfair subscription contracts.

We are processing your request. \n Thank you for your patience. An error occurred. This could be due to inactivity on the page - please try again.