Out-Law / Your Daily Need-To-Know

OUT-LAW NEWS 2 min. read

EU GDPR enforcement puts spotlight on AI-driven recruitment

Businessman looking at job searchDigital  SEOSocialEditorial image

AI-driven recruitment tools are raising data protection concerns. Photo: courtneyk/iStock


As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes a mainstream tool for recruiters, European data protection authorities are being invited to adopt a coordinated response to the data protection issues these types of hiring processes raise.

The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) has selected automated decision-making (ADM), including ADM driven by AI, as the priority enforcement topic for its sixth coordinated enforcement action under the Coordinated Enforcement Framework (CEF).

The EDPB established the CEF in 2021 as part of its ongoing efforts to streamline enforcement and cooperation among data protection authorities (DPAs) across Europe. The EDPB announced last week that ADM would be the focal point of the CEF’s next coordinated action and would “focus on enforcing the right not to be subject to decisions based solely on automated processing and the related right of access.”

In particular, the EDPB said it would examine these rights “in the context of automated candidate screening tools, including AI-driven tools used in recruitment”. The EDPB said the coordinated enforcement action is scheduled to launch in 2027 and that DPAs could join this action on a voluntary basis in the coming weeks.

Malcolm Dowden, a data protection law expert at Pinsent Masons, said it was significant that the EDPB had recognised the growing prevalence of AI recruitment tools and said there is a need for greater regulator and enforcement consistency in this area. “AI tools have been deployed by many organisations throughout the full recruitment lifecycle to streamline the process, from identifying and sifting candidates, to analysing interview responses and managing onboarding,” he said. “At several points in the process, it is possible that key decisions are being made by solely automated means. For example, candidates might be ranked in a way that leads to automatic rejection or them being overlooked by recruiters.”

While Dowden said ADM can occur throughout an end-to-end recruitment process, he said that where that occurs “without meaningful human involvement the decision is likely to engage the automated decision making (ADM) rules in EU GDPR, meaning that the decision will be lawfully made only if specified conditions are met and safeguards put in place.”

Data protection law expert Stephanie Lees of Pinsent Masons said the EDPB’s focus on coordinated enforcement in this area is welcome. In the UK, the Information Commission’s Office (ICO) has already done extensive work on the fair and responsible use of automation in recruitment through its recruitment audits and resulting recommendations, she said.

“A key finding from that work is that tools positioned by recruiters as ‘decision support’ tools often, in practice, involve automated decision-making where candidates are screened or ranked by AI without meaningful human review,” said Lees. “Greater regulatory focus in the EU should help organisations understand where that line is drawn and ensure that appropriate safeguards are built into recruitment processes. This is particularly relevant for clients procuring or adopting global recruitment solutions.”

Any coordinated enforcement by EU supervisory authorities under GDPR would be likely to focus on key stages of AI-driven recruitment processes, from initial screening of CVs and ranking to automatic rejection of candidates.

Lees said now is a critical moment for those recruiters and organisations across EU member states which use these types of hiring practices to take action. “Organisations deploying AI tools for recruitment should examine their processes to identify any points at which decisions with a legal or similarly significant effect are being made and consider whether those decisions can be made with meaningful human involvement so that the ADM rules are not engaged.”

AI has become a standard feature by recruiters in many countries, but there are growing concerns over bias, risk and governance issues inherent in processing personal data using these types of recruitment tools. In the UK, the ICO has warned recruiters that using AI tools for recruitment can pose “inherent risks to people and their privacy”.

The EDPB’s announcement follows its publication of draft guidelines in September for data protection authorities to bring greater consistency to how fines for GDPR breaches are imposed and enforced across the EU. The guidelines include a five-step methodology to help regulators determine the severity of an infringement and whether it requires a financial penalty.

We are processing your request. \n Thank you for your patience. An error occurred. This could be due to inactivity on the page - please try again.