Out-Law / Your Daily Need-To-Know

OUT-LAW ANALYSIS 4 min. read

Digital Fairness: Act proposal puts video game monetisation models in focus

Friends playing video games_Digital - SEOSocialEditorial image

Dimensions/iStock.


Video game developers, publishers and platforms could face more prescriptive EU rules on virtual currencies, loot boxes and other monetisation mechanics under the proposed Digital Fairness Act (DFA), published weeks after consumer authorities opened coordinated enforcement action against nine games companies.

The European Commission published its proposed text for the DFA on 11 November. If adopted as currently proposed, it would introduce specific requirements governing real-money pricing, paid virtual currencies, variable-reward systems, pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanics, and potentially addictive design. It would replace the EU’s Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (UCPD) with a directly applicable regulation that would apply uniformly across all EU countries, although the DFA’s wording may change as it passes through the European Parliament and Council of Ministers.

The proposal follows coordinated action launched by the EU Consumer Protection Cooperation Network (CPCN) on 30 September against the companies behind nine video games, including Candy Crush Saga, Minecraft, Valorant and Clash of Clans. A parallel action involving Activision Blizzard UK Limited concerns the games Diablo Immortal and Call of Duty Mobile. The investigations are ongoing and no breaches of consumer law have been established to date. Alongside the consumer law investigations, the CPCN also published a joint statement on stronger consumer protection in video games.

The actions announced on 30 September seek to enforce the CPCN’s principles on in-game virtual currencies that were published in March 2025. Those principles explain how the authorities consider existing EU consumer law applies to purchasable virtual currencies. They call on games businesses to show real-money prices, avoid currency exchanges that obscure costs, provide clear information before purchase and respect consumers’ withdrawal rights. They also say games should not oblige consumers to buy more currency than they need and should provide appropriate safeguards for children and other vulnerable consumers.

While the September action by the CPCN is testing how established consumer law principles apply to particular games and purchasing journeys, the DFA would go further by placing several of the authorities’ concerns on an express legislative footing.

Article 14 of the proposed DFA would require traders that allow consumers to use paid virtual currencies to buy virtual items or other products from them to display the corresponding monetary value. Where an exact value cannot be calculated, traders would have to provide an estimate based on what the consumer would need to pay, without taking account of volume discounts or promotions.

The value would have to be shown in the currency used to acquire the first paid virtual currency. The requirement would therefore extend to systems involving successive currency conversions. According to the DFA recitals, the value should be displayed prominently, clearly and comprehensibly, irrespective of the virtual currency’s legal classification.

For games businesses, compliance could require changes to item stores, currency bundles, conversion screens and platform interfaces, not merely amendments to terms and conditions. Businesses may also need consistent methods for calculating estimated values where players can acquire the same currency through differently priced bundles.

The DFA would make real-money pricing a specific legislative requirement and could crystallise the direction already being taken by consumer authorities in the EU. When purchasing in-game virtual items using virtual currency, the proposals would also require the real-world monetary value of the virtual item time to be displayed, in a prominent, clear and comprehensible manner, to ensure transparency about the true cost of in-game items.

If implemented as drafted, the DFA would impose additional requirements where a game is directed at children, or the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that children use it. In those circumstances, the acquisition of paid virtual currencies would have to be disabled by default and activated only with the approval of a parent or guardian.

Article 15 of the proposed DFA would regulate paid variable-reward systems, including loot boxes, wheels of fortune and collectible card packs. Traders would have to disclose the virtual items that could be obtained and the probability of obtaining them. Consumers would also need an effective and easily accessible means of disabling paid variable-reward systems.

Paid variable-reward systems would have to be disabled for children where the game is directed at them or the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that they use it. The provision could therefore affect games that are not specifically marketed to children, depending on how the final legislation applies the knowledge threshold.

Article 16 of the proposed DFA would further prohibit traders from offering pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanisms to children in the same circumstances. The recitals refer to mechanics that create artificial difficulty barriers, make the unpaid route to progression illusory, or allow spending effectively to determine competitive outcomes.

The proposed DFA provisions, which target ‘spending-maximising’ practices, could have significant consequences for free-to-play and freemium games that rely on in-game purchases.

The Commission’s impact assessment identifies video games as the sector in which spending-maximising features are used most prominently and widely. It cites an enforcement sweep in which loot boxes appeared in 46% of the games examined, 78% of which used virtual currencies.

The DFA’s impact would extend well beyond payment mechanics, including areas such as ‘addictive design’ and ‘dark patterns’.

Compliance will be a product and technology issue as well as a legal one. Real-money price displays, parental approval, default settings, probability disclosures and effective controls may require coordinated changes across legal, commercial, design and engineering teams.

The September investigations seek to apply existing EU consumer law to identified games and purchasing journeys, whilst the DFA would turn several of the authorities’ positions into more detailed and directly applicable legal requirements. Games companies should not assume that the legislative process places current compliance risk on hold, particularly given the CPCN considers that existing consumer law already applies to virtual-currency practices.

Games businesses should map where paid currencies, successive currency exchanges, random rewards, progression purchases and engagement incentives appear across their portfolios. They may also need to review real-money price displays, bundle structures, probability disclosures, age-rating and audience evidence, child accounts, parental approval processes, default settings and consumer controls. Contractual terms, withdrawal processes and refund policies also remain relevant to the CPCN’s current enforcement action.

We are processing your request. \n Thank you for your patience. An error occurred. This could be due to inactivity on the page - please try again.