OUT-LAW NEWS

Magnum pursues Aldi over alleged ‘copycat’ ice cream packaging

Magnum cornetto and ben and jerrys ice cream_Digital - SEOSocialEditorial image

Magnum Ice Cream Company is the company behind popular brands such as Magnum, Ben and Jerry’s, and Cornetto. John Keeble/Getty Images.


Magnum Ice Cream Company, owner of the Magnum ice cream brand, has initiated legal proceedings against supermarket chain Aldi for alleged trade mark infringement and ‘passing off’ in Ireland.

According to the Irish Times, the brand owner believes Aldi’s packaging for its rival ‘Gianni’ range of products is identical or confusingly similar to its packaging for its Magnum ice creams. It reported that Magnum undertook a review of Aldi’s rival products late last year. The outcome was that Magnum believes the branding and packaging Aldi has used for its ‘Gianni’ range has evolved over time to be more like that used for the Magnum product range.

Out-Law has asked Aldi for its response to the claims.

Under Irish trade mark law, if similarities between a trade mark and rival branding creates a likelihood of confusion among consumers, including a risk that the rival products will be associated with the earlier trade mark, then the rival brand owner may be liable for trade mark infringement.

Trade mark infringement can also be claimed if unauthorised third party use of a trade mark without due cause takes unfair advantage of, or is detrimental to, the distinctive character or reputation of the earlier trade mark.

Passing off is a common law tort in Ireland. To succeed with such claims, brand owners need to establish goodwill, misrepresentation and damage.

On goodwill, brand owners need to show that there is protectable goodwill in Ireland associated with their brand. They then need to show that third party use amounts to a misrepresentation likely to lead consumers to believe that the third party’s goods are its, or that there is some commercial connection, authorisation or association between the two. Brand owners then have to show actual or likely damage to its goodwill. That could take the form of diverted sales, a loss of control over its reputation, or harm caused by consumers incorrectly associating a third party’s goods with those of the brand owner.

There are potential defences to trade mark infringement claims in Ireland.

Where a rights holder becomes aware of potentially infringing activity but allows it to continue without objection, particularly where the other party continues to invest in or develop its business in the meantime, that conduct may become relevant to the relief ultimately available.

We are processing your request. \n Thank you for your patience. An error occurred. This could be due to inactivity on the page - please try again.