The UK’s data protection regulator has raised concerns about the growing use of smart glasses and the challenges they pose for privacy and transparency. In a blog published on the ICO’s website Paul Arnold, chief executive of the Information Commissioner’s Office, has highlighted reports of people being recorded without their knowledge, raising serious questions about surveillance, safety, and trust. He is urging organisations to build privacy safeguards into the technology while recognising its potential benefits.
At EU level, Arnold’s intervention has been followed by a statement and accompanying report from the European Data Protection Board highlighting similar concerns, particularly in sensitive environments such as workplaces. Meanwhile, the European Consumer Organisation, BEUC, has called for an investigation into the privacy and covert surveillance risks associated with smart glasses. So what does this mean for employers and their responsibilities under UK GDPR? We’ll ask a data protection expert.
Smart glasses are wearable devices that look much like ordinary spectacles but incorporate technology such as cameras, microphones, and artificial intelligence. Depending on the model, they can record video, capture conversations, provide information to the wearer and connect to external digital services. They are finding practical applications in the workplace, from providing remote assistance to engineers to helping employees access information while carrying out their duties. They also offer important accessibility benefits, including help for people with impaired vision.
But their growing use is prompting questions about where and when they should be permitted. HM Courts & Tribunals Service has already prohibited Meta smart glasses in courts and tribunals in England and Wales, reflecting concerns about unauthorised recording.
For employers, the challenge is to accommodate legitimate uses of the technology while protecting the personal information of employees, customers, and visitors.
Eilidh Collins is a data protection expert at Pinsent Masons and earlier she joined me by phone from Edinburgh to discuss the implications for employers. So why are smart glasses attracting increasing attention from data protection regulators?
Eilidh Collins: “So we know that the first data protection principle is that any processing of personal data should be fair, lawful, and transparent and it's this transparency issue that's really got regulators a bit concerned about the use of smart glasses and that really stems from the covert nature of recording that can come through smart glasses. So, the advanced tech that's used in smart glasses can often mean that they look like a regular pair of glasses, and someone might be recording you without you necessarily knowing about it. So, for example, if an employee is wearing a pair of smart glasses, they could be recording a meeting with a colleague, a customer interaction, anything really, without the other party knowing they're being recorded and that's different to a phone being held up or a camera being in front of you, in which case you would know that you are being recorded. So that transparency piece really comes into it there. The risks also extend beyond that of deliberate recording piece because the glasses can capture what that person is seeing. We often see that an employee using them could inadvertently capture colleagues' faces, documents on desks, you know, if they're walking through an office, things that are on people's screens which are quite confidential, and that data is all being captured by these glasses and processed. So this is causing a bit of concern to regulators because if individuals don't know they're being recorded and their data is being processed, then it's really hard for them to exercise their data privacy rights in respect of that information. So the EDPB's October statement definitely highlights this difficulty, particularly in workplaces and other environments where individuals might have some limited control over what is being recorded.”
Joe Glavina: “When smart glasses are used in the workplace, how does UK GDPR apply and who is responsible for complying with it?”
Eilidh Collins: “So I think some employers might assume that if an employee owns smart glasses, brings them to work, and uses them without explicit permission, then therefore the employer doesn't really have any data protection obligations in respect of them. But that would be a really big oversimplification of the data protection regime, and who is responsible for data protection compliance in respect of that data is going to depend on a number of different factors. So there are some fairly straightforward scenarios that if an employer owns the smart glasses, gives them to employees, and says, "please use these for these defined purposes," then I think in that situation it's pretty clear that it's going to be the employer's compliance role there. The more difficult situation arises where an employee brings their own smart glasses to work and records, maybe, customers or colleagues without permission. In that situation, whether the employer could be held responsible for that data processing will depend on the circumstances, including what's the purpose of that recording and what's the employer's involvement in that recording? Have they spoken to the employee about it? Do they have knowledge about it? So it's not just as straightforward as who owns the device. So employers really need to be aware that obligations under data protection law may arise from employees' use of smart glasses and, if they do, the employer might have to consider the lawful basis, any appropriate transparency requirements, and any additional considerations if special category data as being processed as well.”
Joe Glavina: “How do AI-enabled features and external services increase the data protection risks for employers?”
Eilidh Collins: “So put simply, there is a bit of a risk to employers that they're losing some control over this data. So employers, as data controllers, have a number of obligations in respect of the data that they control and process and utilising those AI-enabled features, or a number of other features on smart glasses, involves the transmission of, and sometimes storage of, data on external servers, in apps, or in various cloud storage platforms. So, to explain that in a bit more detail, if an employee is using smart glasses to, say, provide an ongoing summary of a meeting they're attending, that is necessarily involving the transmission of data from that meeting to another location, so that might be in the cloud somewhere, it might be on an external server, but what should cause concern for an employer in that situation is we don't necessarily know where that data is sitting, and that is an issue if the employer is the controller of that data. There's real risk that we don’t know where that data is going, so therefore, if smart glasses are used in the workplace, there's a risk that sensitive data, including employee data, but also commercially sensitive data that's not necessarily personal information, could end up in external locations that the employer doesn't really have full visibility of, and that can cause real issues in data protection compliance because the employer cannot establish where the information is being held, whether it's accessible to third parties, how long it's being retained for, and whether it might be transferred outside the UK, which presents a lot of practical challenges. Further, if employees are using personally owned smart glasses, there's also a risk that they could retain access to sensitive information well after their employment is concluded, and that raises practical concerns around who's got access to your data, what the deletion protocols are, the security of the data and, ultimately, the employer's ability to comply with data protection legislation. I think it's also worth noting that whilst we're looking at this from a data protection perspective, this isn't just necessarily a risk for personal data. It's also a risk for sensitive commercial data as well that wouldn't necessarily be covered by the same regimes but would also cause concern for employers.”
So the message for employers is not to wait until smart glasses become a problem in the workplace. The technology may have legitimate business benefits, but employers need to understand the data protection risks, including when they may be responsible for information captured by employees using their own devices.
Eilidh and the data protection team are currently advising a number of employers on these issues. If you would like advice on managing the risks associated with smart glasses and other AI-enabled technologies please contact Eilidh – her details are on the screen for you.