Intergraph alleged that it owns two patents covering parallel instruction computing (PIC). PIC technology is used in Intel’s Itanium, a high-performance chip that runs powerful computers and servers.
The federal judge accepted Intergraph’s arguments and found that its patents are “valid and enforceable.” He ruled that Itanium infringed on designs embodied in the two patents and in the Clipper processor, formerly used in Intergraph’s workstations.
Intel has spent 10 years and $1 billion in developing Itanium. However, its liability is limited to $250 million, following a deal reached between the companies in settling a previous patent dispute – a settlement which resulted in Intel agreeing to pay Intergraph the sum of $300 miillion.
A spokesman for Intel said that the company intends to file a motion for reconsideration. If the company appeals the ruling and loses, it will have to pay an additional $100 million to license Intergraph’s technology, under the terms of the previous settlement.