Out-Law News

Microsoft again asks Supreme Court to overturn antitrust ruling


Microsoft yesterday called for the US Supreme Court to reject government arguments and to reverse the finding of the Appeals Court that the company had breached antitrust laws. In a legal brief which attacked each of the arguments made by the Department of Justice, the company said that district court judge Thomas Penfield Jackson’s misconduct was “so profound that it is difficult to imagine a case in which a new trial would be more appropriate.”

The case was recently sent to a new district court judge, Colleen Kollar-Kotelly, following criticism by the Appeals Court of Judge Jackson’s comments about the case which Jackson made to journalists before announcing his findings and proposed remedy. The Appeals Court charged Judge Kollar-Kotelly with deciding certain questions of law and proposing a new remedy. The Department of Justice recently indicated that it no longer wanted the remedy to be a break-up of Microsoft, the original remedy that had been supported by Judge Jackson.

Microsoft is arguing to the Supreme Court that the Appeals Court did not go far enough in throwing out Jackson’s remedy. It argues that the Appeals Court should have thrown out his entire verdict, essentially necessitating a re-trial. The Department of Justice disagrees.

The Department of Justice and Microsoft are tomorrow due to address Judge Kollar-Kotelly on outstanding issues to be followed by a hearing next week.

We are processing your request. \n Thank you for your patience. An error occurred. This could be due to inactivity on the page - please try again.