The Autumn Budget has delivered mixed news for employee share ownership, with new tax incentives for company founders but concerns that some of the benefits could be difficult to access. For employers, the changes raise important questions about how effectively share schemes can help attract, reward, and retain talent.
The Chancellor, John Healey, announced a new Founders' Relief in his Budget on 28 October, offering a reduced capital gains tax rate of 10% on lifetime gains of up to £10 million for qualifying company founders. But strict qualifying conditions could limit who benefits. At the same time, the lifetime limit under the existing Business Asset Disposal Relief is being halved from £1 million to £500,000.
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of England and Wales has warned that the qualifying conditions could leave many entrepreneurs disappointed, despite the apparent generosity of the new relief. Meanwhile, the government is consulting on the detailed Founders' Relief rules until 30 November, giving businesses an opportunity to raise concerns before they are finalised. We'll speak to a share plans expert about that.
Beyond Founders' Relief, the Budget also brings changes to Enterprise Management Incentives, or EMI. From April 2027, the period during which employees can exercise options following certain disqualifying events while retaining favourable tax treatment will double from 90 to 180 days. But employers with existing schemes will need to be careful about changing their option agreements.
The government has also stopped short of shortening the qualifying periods for all-employee schemes such as SIP and SAYE, a disappointment for businesses with shorter-serving workforces, particularly in retail and hospitality.
So, while some of the Budget measures could make share incentives more attractive, others may offer limited practical benefits. Employers will need to assess what the changes mean for their existing arrangements and their wider reward strategies.
Ian Shaw is a share plans specialist at Pinsent Masons and earlier he joined me by video-link to discuss the changes. So, how significant is the proposed new Founders' Relief?
Ian Shaw: “Well, this is met with very different reactions. Some people are saying it's a great new generous relief. Others are saying, well, it's essentially, for those of us with longer memories, entrepreneurs' relief, as business asset disposal relief was then called, but effectively with a new name and a lot more limiting conditions. It looks on paper like a great relief. You can pay a much lower rate of capital gains tax if you're a founder on a lifetime limit of up to £10 million, which seems very generous given business asset disposal relief was up to a million but, again, those of us will remember that that was the limit for entrepreneurs' relief. Who will benefit? Well, there's no real tax certainty in some ways because you can meet the individual conditions, but there are also conditions on the turnover of your company, the number of employees recruited per year, headcount, and R&D spend. Now, the government is consulting on those, so if you have a view on those, please have a quick look over the consultation, or just phone your contact in the Pinsent Masons Share Incentives Department, and we'll run through a simplified version with you, and we are actually feeding back to the government's consultation, collating clients' responses and now really is the time, if we think there are practical difficulties or logistical difficulties with meeting any of those tests, to tell the government because they're not necessarily an industry, and they won't see what we see on the everyday. So, if you want your voice to be heard, please feed it back to your Pinsent Masons contact. We'll collate the responses, and we'll put all those into a strong submission to the government.”
Joe Glavina: “What opportunities has the government missed to improve all employee share schemes?”
Ian Shaw: “Well, it's a real shame that they didn't do something about share incentive plans, SIPs, or save as you earn, also known as share save and SAYE. Perhaps they thought they'd done enough for one budget in the employee share ownership field. But for those schemes, essentially, you need to have held the incentive for three years, or for SIPs to get the best tax treatment you need to have held it for five. Now there are plenty of industries such as retail and hospitality where people don't stick around for that long. That doesn't mean the company is a bad company, it’s just the nature of the industry. Now, why they shouldn't be able to benefit from this great tax advantaged scheme and align themselves with shareholders and investors, if they only stay around for a year or two, remains to be seen. I think that probably will change. There's a lot of pressure from industry bodies for it to do so, but I think that has possibly been put on the too difficult pile for now, but I think we may well see something in the next budget about that, especially if that's just before an election.”
Joe Glavina: “What difference will the extension of the EMI exercise period following disqualifying events make in practice, in your view?”
Ian Shaw: “Well, I don't think that's quite as earth-shattering as the previous changes. I think the previous changes to increase the gross assets test really has been a game-changer and we found some of our smaller AIM-listed companies who've started to qualify when previously they didn't, and also the number of employees you're allowed has also dramatically increased. So it's definitely worth just dusting off with your lawyers whether you can do EMI when you previously couldn't. I think the disqualifying event, how long you're allowed to keep the tax treatment for after the option has been disqualified, is a little bit of tinkering around the edges. It could, of course, help in some cases, but if you don't have an exit after 90 days, you probably won't have one after 180 days. So it could help in some very narrow circumstances, but I'm not sure it will be a particular game changer as previous recent changes have been. I think also we need to be very careful that we check whether the government allows you to amend your scheme to put in the 180 days. If you've got a lapse provision, for instance, after 90 days, don't automatically assume that you can change that to 180 days because, broadly, changes to EMI options which are existing can end up in effectively those grants being treated as the grant of a new option, which basically means you lose your good tax treatment. So, the government may well, and hopefully will, take the same approach as it did when it extended the grant period to 15 years and allowed companies to make that change without wrecking the tax treatment of existing options. But that remains to be seen. Definitely before you go ahead and do anything like this, do check in with your lawyers?”
Joe Glavina: “So overall, Ian, to what extent has this Budget helped employers attract and retain talent which is really what it's all about as far as our HR viewers are concerned?”
Ian Shaw: “Absolutely. I think if you're in a small company where people may be benefiting from big gains on EMI options, business asset disposal relief, which was of course previously entrepreneurs’ relief, that's been cut how much you're allowed to make in your lifetime from a million pounds of the gains to £500,000 of the gains, and that's a lifetime limit. So that would make your EMI scheme less attractive to people potentially and, of course, only a very few people will be getting the new founders relief. So I think CSOP, which we've covered on another programme, super important, that could really help attract and bring talent to the UK. Dust off EMI – again, I don't think the recent change makes too much of a difference, but certainly the opening up of the conditions relatively recently has, and I think it's very much watch this space for changes to SAYE and SIP. My prediction, Joe, that'll be coming in the next Budget.”
So, the key message for employers is that there is still an opportunity to influence the final rules on Founders’ Relief, with the government’s consultation closing on 30 November. Ian is currently gathering clients’ views on the proposals and would welcome feedback, particularly on any practical difficulties with the qualifying conditions. If you would like to contribute to Pinsent Masons’ consultation response, please do contact Ian. His details are there on screen for you.