Decision in Judicial Review by claimants in Film Partnerships promoted by Ingenious Media

31 Jul 2015 | 04:49 pm | 1 min. read

The decision has been released today in the case of Nigel Rowe, Alec David Worrall & Others v HMRC [2015] EWHC 2293 (Admin) which involved a challenge by way of judicial review to partner payment notices (PPNs) issued by HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) to members of limited liability partnerships (LLPs) set up by Ingenious Media plc. In the decision Mrs Justice Simler DBE dismissed the judicial review.

Pinsent Masons LLP are the solicitors acting for Messrs Rowe and Worrall and the 150 plus other claimants involved.

Jason Collins, Head of Tax at international law firm Pinsent Masons LLP said:

"We are disappointed by the judgment, which in our view does not does not adequately address a number of serious issues raised by this new legislation.  For many of the claimants, HMRC checked and repaid the tax in question over 10 years ago when it could have instead held on to the money pending any further investigations – yet it is now trying to use new legislation to claw money back. 

In many cases, the claimants also say that HMRC has not followed proper procedures and is now out of time to recover any tax, whatever the merits of the underlying dispute.

We are taking instructions from the claimants. As this is a large group of claimants for whom this is also news today, we are unable to comment further at this time."

Accelerated payment notices (APNs) were introduced in July 2014 and allow HMRC to demand the payment of disputed tax associated with a tax avoidance scheme up front – before a tribunal or court has decided whether or not a scheme is effective. PPNs are similar to APNs but are used where a notice is given to a member of a partnership or an LLP.

APNs and PPNs can be issued where schemes demonstrate certain 'avoidance hallmarks'; such as the scheme being subject to disclosure requirements under the Disclosure of Tax Avoidance Schemes (DOTAS) rules. APNs or PPNs can be issued in relation to schemes that were entered into before the APN and PPN legislation came into force. Before APNs and PPNs were introduced HMRC had to win a tribunal case before it could demand disputed tax in these cases – except where repayments of tax were claimed, in which case HMRC already had the power to hold the money in dispute. Accelerated payments will be repaid with interest in the event that the scheme is ultimately proved to work.

Key Contacts

Jason Collins

Jason Collins

Partner, Head of Litigation, Regulatory & Tax

View Profile

Latest press releases

Show me all press releases

Pinsent Masons publishes its 2020 pay gap report

Pay gap reporting highlights the value and importance of our drive to promote diversity and inclusion. This year we have opted to report on our disability pay gap for the first time as we underscore our commitment to belonging and inclusion and strengthen our network groups to encourage and champion change for all of our people.

Pinsent Masons advises Sanne Group on first specialised depositary services licence in Ireland

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has advised global fund administrator Sanne Group on the first specialised depositary licence to be granted by the Central Bank of Ireland, further enhancing Sanne’s capabilities in Ireland and its multi-jurisdictional proposition for alternative fund managers.

Pinsent Masons provides legal advice in breakthrough data trust report for food industry

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has provided the legal advice in a set of new reports recommending the latest innovation in the burgeoning technology of data trusts.

People who viewed this press release also viewed

Show me all press releases

Pinsent Masons publishes its 2020 pay gap report

Pay gap reporting highlights the value and importance of our drive to promote diversity and inclusion. This year we have opted to report on our disability pay gap for the first time as we underscore our commitment to belonging and inclusion and strengthen our network groups to encourage and champion change for all of our people.

For all media enquiries, including arranging an interview with one of our spokespeople, please contact the press office on

+44 (0)20 7418 8199 or 

Location contacts