The challenge businesses face is not simply to find a competent local lawyer. It is to ensure that local proceedings form part of a coherent overarching strategy that reflects their commercial objectives, project position and wider international exposure. Businesses need to select legal advisers that can lead them with the delivery of that strategy.
International disputes presented in local courts frequently involve questions of international practice and procedure, require deep technical and sector understanding, and demand a coherent strategic plan from the outset. They may include multiple international parties and therefore may fit into a wider international strategy.
The role of the lead legal advisers should be to develop the overarching case strategy for dispute resolution and ensure that the local counsel they engage understand all of the relevant elements, as well as their place within the client's wider dispute position. That strategic oversight is what transforms local court proceedings from an isolated exercise into part of an integrated international response.
Construction and energy projects generate disputes that are technically, contractually and commercially complex. Local court proceedings arising from those projects carry additional layers of difficulty: an unfamiliar procedural environment, potentially limited local experience of the relevant contract forms, and the risk that local proceedings become disconnected from the broader international dispute strategy.
Being able to lean on legal advisers that know how to manage the intersection between local court proceedings and the international context in which they arise will be important.
No one law firm has a presence in every geographic market, so businesses should look to legal advisers that have cultivated a network of skilled and experienced local lawyers, who they can engage at speed to provide jurisdiction-specific advice on law and court procedure, and undertake the relevant advocacy, in key jurisdictions where they do not have a direct presence.
This approach ensures that the business can be confident that proper understanding of the implication of foreign legal concepts and how decisions are made and documented within complex project organisations is brought to bear in the local advice that is delivered. This will reduce the risk of something critical being lost between the client, international counsel and local representation, a risk that can otherwise have significant consequences for case strategy, outcome and cost.
For businesses, this model is well proven and effective. It means that their legal advisers serve as their strategic lead and single point of coordination, while leaving oversight of matters at local level to those trusted advisers.
Legal advisers should be able to help businesses identify and select appropriate local counsel right for them, with reference to scope and budgets, and support with challenging assumptions and establishing clear reporting lines.
Once engaged, the work done by local counsel needs to be supervised, coordinated and, for key work product, reviewed. Businesses should expect their legal advisers to be able to do all those things and, most importantly, ensure that the local work is aligned with the broader case strategy. Where an international dispute generates large or complex volumes of local advice across multiple jurisdictions, it is vital that the advice businesses obtain from local counsel is distilled in such a way into it enables them to make informed decisions and avoids the management team having to navigate multiple streams of unfamiliar foreign-law advice unaided.
Legal advisers that are experienced in working with co-counsel can ensure there is focus on a common approach and an appropriate division of responsibilities, so that there is no ambiguity about who is responsible for each element of a matter.
Allying an understanding of local procedural law with deep sectoral experience is vital within a legal service offering. For construction, energy and infrastructure projects, businesses should be seeking advisers that have experience advising on matters such as:
- delay, disruption and prolongation claims;
- variation and change order disputes;
- termination and re-letting;
- performance bonds, guarantees and letters of credit;
- technical performance and defects;
- joint ventures, consortiums and subcontractor claims;
- project finance and lender-related disputes.
Where sector knowledge is lacking, businesses cannot be confident that their legal advisers can sufficiently interrogate the facts and technical evidence alongside local counsel, and won’t wrongly treat the dispute simply as a question of local procedural law.
For businesses with an international project portfolio, this model of legal management offers simplicity and reliability for managing local court disputes globally. It means there is no need to build and manage a new legal team every time a dispute arises in a new country and that there is continuity in terms of the overall strategy, selection and management of appropriate local lawyers, coordination over parallel proceedings and translation of complex local legal advice into practical decisions. It brings the benefit of local lawyers with local rights of audience and knowledge of the local law and domestic courts together with an international team the business can trust to maintain strategy, consistency, quality, communication and cost control.
That combination is increasingly important as energy and infrastructure clients expand into jurisdictions and projects that require the engagement of local lawyers or engagement in local court process, or where a single dispute spans several legal systems simultaneously.
The objective is not to undermine the importance of local counsel. It is to make local counsel part of an integrated international disputes team, one that is centred on the client's commercial objectives and built around the realities of international project delivery.