Out-Law / Your Daily Need-To-Know

Microsoft yesterday submitted a brief to the Supreme Court asking for its anti-trust case to be sent back to a federal appeals court instead of proceeding straight to the higher court. The Justice Department, which is in favour of a Supreme Court hearing, is expected to respond to Microsoft’s latest move by 14th August.
In justifying its request, Microsoft made reference to the number of errors made in the trial court which concluded that the company should be split into two separate entities. The division was suspended pending the appeal court decision.

Microsoft explained its view of the issue, stating:

“The severity of the remedy imposed and the significance of the case to the nation’s economy make it more important – not less – that these appeals proceed through intermediate appellate review in the normal course.”

US federal law provides that large anti-trust cases can bypass the appeals court and proceed directly to the Supreme Court. However, Microsoft argues that an appeal court’s powers would enable it to look at all aspects of the case in greater depth than the Supreme Court could.

The final decision as to the court in which the next stage of the case will be heard is expected to be taken by nine justices of the Supreme Court no earlier than September.

We are processing your request. \n Thank you for your patience. An error occurred. This could be due to inactivity on the page - please try again.