Howard Taylor claimed in his defence that he was planning to set up a fan club for Williams. According to the report by a WIPO dispute resolution panel:
"He pointed the domain name to the Oasis site to be controversial, to draw attention to the site, and to see what interest there was in .info. He thought that the ‘rift’ between Robbie Williams and Mr Gallagher of Oasis was a public relations exercise and ‘that anyone who knows about it would see the humour’. There were only 50 hits to his site in 6 months (half of which were caused by himself) and he does not believe any harm would come to the Complainant. Once the Complaint was received, he redirected the site as soon as was practicable to the Complainant's site."
In fact, the domain pointed to Google’s search results for “Robbie Williams” the first result being the official site.
The WIPO panelist, noting that Taylor also owned ScottishWidows.info and PrincessDi.info, ordered him to transfer the domain to Williams, reasoning that it was registered in bad faith. He said in the decision: “This does not appear to be the action of a fan, but rather the action of someone who wished to provoke the Complainant.”