Dr Andreas Schöberle, an employment law expert with Pinsent Masons in Munich, was commenting as the German Federal Cabinet adopted a bill that is expected to introduce sweeping changes to termination protections for high-earning employees in Germany.
The draft bill, which was adopted on 13 November, proposes replacing traditional protections against dismissal with a severance pay option for employees whose income exceeds 1.75 times the contribution assessment ceiling for the German social security system.
This is initially expected to affect employees with an annual income exceeding €177,450 gross. However, in light of the planned increase in the basic pension threshold from 2027, the threshold for the new termination option is also expected to increase, meaning that from 1 January 2027 it will affect employees earning in excess of €180,000.
This income takes into account employees’ company pension scheme contributions and the monetary benefit of a company car used for private purposes. However, performance-related bonuses, profit-sharing payments and benefits not specified in the contract will not be included.
The change is expected to have a significant effect on Germany’s employment landscape, as high severance payments for executives have been widespread to date. Until now, executives have benefited from a strong negotiating position over their employers thanks to strict termination protection provisions in Germany.
Commenting on the changes, Schöberle said: “The new provision allows a request for termination without giving reasons, which also has retroactive effect from the start of the notice period. This is expected to weaken managers’ leverage and bargaining power. The level of severance pay for high earners is therefore likely to be more closely aligned with the statutory maximum amounts.”
While the proposals will grant employers greater flexibility in the event of terminations, for high-earning employees, termination payments are likely to be more difficult to secure even in the context of settlement negotiations.
If the dismissal is deemed unfair and upheld because the court does not recognise the ground for dismissal put forward by the employer as sufficient, then what the draft refers to as a “shift from protection of employment to protection against dismissal with severance pay” comes into play.
In such cases, the employer may apply for termination in return for a severance payment without giving reasons. Consequently, even employees who are successful in proceedings cannot enforce their continued employment through the courts. The termination takes effect in return for a court-determined severance payment, which is typically between one and 12 months’ worth of salary depending on the case’s particular circumstances.
The draft bill emphasises that protection against dismissal will not be completely abolished for affected high earners concerned and that the requirements of the Protection Against Dismissal Act must continue to be met. However, in practice only the special protection against dismissal and the requirement for consultation with the works council will be maintained.
These changes will not affect the general conditions around termination protection in Germany under the Protection Against Dismissals Act, which applies to employees after six months of continuous service in businesses with more than 10 employees.
The bill also proposes a number of other potentially significant changes for employees and employers, including giving employers greater flexibility to offer more fixed-term employment contracts for longer periods; creating tougher rules governing employees taking sick leave; and making it easier for companies with a works council to implement and update software.
The legislation is expected to enter into force in early 2027. Schöberle said companies in Germany should review their remuneration structures in good time and adapt their termination procedures accordingly.
As only fixed components will be taken into account in the income assessment, he said companies should recalibrate their remuneration structures and adjust the ratio of fixed to variable pay in line with the new regulations. “When considering parting ways with high-earning employees, companies should also assess whether it is possible to wait until the new regulations come into force, thereby securing a stronger negotiating position,” he added.