Out-Law / Your Daily Need-To-Know

OUT-LAW NEWS 3 min. read

British Ports Association calls for harbour orders process overhaul

large ship in the water_Digital - SEOSocialEditorial image

The BPA says reforms would streamline and modernise the harbour order regime in England. Photo: Laurence Berger/iStock


A national trade body for UK ports and harbours has called for wide-ranging reforms to the harbour orders process in England

 

The proposals were published by the BPA last week as part of a series of measures (30 pages / 681KB PDF) put forward to overhaul the current harbour orders process, which has been criticised for unduly delaying investment, affecting project sequencing and financing at English ports.

In England, ports are required to obtain harbour revision orders or harbour empowerment orders for consent to build or expand certain infrastructure developments, to change harbour limits, to obtain new statutory powers to regulate harbours or in relation to constitutional matters.

However, the processing time for these orders can easily take up to four or five years and, in some cases, even longer. The BPA says this is largely down to the unnecessary complexity of the current regime, which it says is too “slow, resource-intensive and increasingly unsuited to routine statutory modernisation.”

In February, the Department for Transport, in tandem with the Marine Management Organisation (MMO), which regulates and oversees marine activities within the United Kingdom, introduced a prioritisation framework in response to what it identified as a “significant caseload” of harbour order applications from ports. The framework established new criteria to help the MMO determine whether to allow qualifying applications to be progressed more quickly towards a parliamentary laying date.

However, the BPA said this framework was only a temporary fix and failed to address the “underlying design” of a system clearly under immense strain. The trade body says the current framework has failed “to adequately differentiate between relatively straightforward statutory modernisation” and orders that were much more “complex”, resulting in a process which was unnecessarily cumbersome and time-consuming. It argues that port owners should also have “greater scope” “to standardise established provisions and concentrate detailed scrutiny on what is genuinely novel, contentious or locally significant.”

The BPA says a three-pronged approach to modernise the statutory framework is now necessary to reduce existing delays and improve the management of current applications; to reduce the demand for harbour orders by improving the process for applications which genuinely require statutory provision; and finally to clear the current backlog by bringing about longer-term reform aimed at modernising the overall harbour orders regime and reduce the number of applications.

Robbie Owen, a port and infrastructure planning expert at Pinsent Masons, who was part of the working group convened by the BPA to re-evaluate the harbour orders regime, said the report should be a wake-up call for the government. “The report will undoubtedly help to highlight the unacceptable issues encountered by those seeking harbour orders in England, which have largely been overlooked in recent and ongoing planning reforms,” he said. “If the need for and process relating to harbour orders can be substantially improved, then they may become an attractive alternative to development consent orders in appropriate cases of harbour infrastructure development, making use of the new ability under the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 to seek a ‘direction out’ of the development consent order (DCO) regime from ministers.”

The report puts forward 19 recommendations, calling on ministers to give harbour authorities in England a common set of statutory powers and remove the existing requirement to lay routine orders before parliament in order to clear the existing backlog. The BPA says that existing harbour authorities should also benefit from any resulting reforms, including where a change in the law might remove the need for their application altogether.

In October the government published a long-awaited revision of its national policy statement (NPS) for ports, which highlighted the “compelling” need for additional port capacity, and the “substantial weight” that should be given to the economic benefits of ports.

However, Owen said the BPA’s report highlighted the urgent need for immediate reform. “The three limbs of the report – dealing with the current severe backlog of undetermined applications, reforming the scope of harbour orders and their procedure, and recommending various new general powers for all statutory harbour authorities in order to avoid asking for them through individual harbour orders – would need to be addressed by government, and by the Marine Management Organisation which is responsible for processing and determining applications for harbour orders, in various different ways,” he said.

While the report only relates to England, Owen said many of the recommendations are equally applicable to harbour orders in Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales, where many of the same problems and issues also exist and the background legislation is much the same. He said he expected the governments in the devolved administrations to consider the report’s findings with interest.

The UK government’s revised NPS acknowledged the ongoing debate surrounding designing and operating ports to minimise greenhouse gas emissions. The failure by some port owners to factor ship emissions into the environmental impact assessments undertaken for major projects has been criticised for leaving some major projects vulnerable to judicial review challenge.

Owen said the BPA’s recommendations would have wider ramifications beyond the maritime sector. “This isn’t just an interesting report dealing with an esoteric area of planning law,” he said. “At its heart is making sure that statutory harbour authorities have access to the powers they need to compete in a modern economy or, where they don’t, that a suitable and proportionate process exists for them seek them. This is fundamental to the role these bodies play in the UK’s international trade, national resilience and competitiveness, the clean energy transition and moving towards net zero.”

We are processing your request. \n Thank you for your patience. An error occurred. This could be due to inactivity on the page - please try again.