More criminal prosecutions for tax evasion as taxpayers lose the right to automatic immunity under new civil investigation rules

05 Jan 2012 | 05:00 pm | 2 min. read

Taxpayers face a much greater risk of criminal prosecution for tax evasion under new rules to be introduced by HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC), and which will come into force on 31 January 2012, according to tax investigation specialists at international law firm Pinsent Masons.

  • Criminal prosecutions up 38% this year
  • Target of fivefold increase in prosecutions 

Under the current rules, known as the Civil Investigation of Fraud process, taxpayers under civil investigation for tax evasion have automatic immunity from criminal prosecution. If HMRC opts to bring a civil investigation, it cannot then mount a criminal prosecution for the same offence.

The new rules, called the Contractual Disclosure Facility, mean that taxpayers suspected of fraud will not get automatic immunity from criminal prosecution. Taxpayers approached under the new rules will be invited to admit tax irregularities, and give details of their offences. Failure to do so will mean that they do not get immunity from prosecution for those offences.

Taxpayers who face a civil investigation can be fined up to 200% of the tax due. With a criminal prosecution, however, taxpayers face an unlimited prison sentence, in addition to the confiscation of assets, which can include the family home.

Pinsent Masons says that HMRC is under immense pressure to prosecute more taxpayers for tax evasion and so is likely to make extensive use of the new powers.

HMRC was set a target of increasing criminal prosecutions for tax evasion fivefold at the Spending Review last October. Figures obtained by Pinsent Masons from HMRC show that criminal convictions for tax evasion have jumped by 38% already in the last year to 148.

Phil Berwick, Director at Pinsent Masons, comments: “This new procedure represents a significant change in the way HMRC conducts investigations where fraud is suspected. The change will help facilitate a very substantial increase in criminal prosecutions in the next few years.”

“Taxpayers will be at greater risk of imprisonment and losing the family home. For the more determined tax evaders, the chances of getting off with a fine and a slap on the wrist are diminishing.”

He adds: “HMRC is hamstrung under the current rules because it has to weigh up the probability of securing a criminal conviction against a civil settlement. It’s much easier to secure a civil settlement, which means HMRC is often reluctant to take a gamble on criminal proceedings, where the burden of proof is higher. In effect, HMRC now gets two bites of the cherry.”

According to a report published by the National Audit Office, in around 20 per cent of civil investigations taxpayers did not cooperate by making disclosures about their tax affairs.

The changes to the rules governing civil investigations should mean that, particularly in cases where individuals refuse to cooperate, HMRC will retain the option of bringing a criminal prosecution. 

Phil Berwick says: “Under the current rules a significant minority of individuals have been stonewalling the Revenue, thwarting the process. HMRC will now have the option of hauling those individuals in front of the criminal courts, the threat of which alone should prompt greater cooperation from taxpayers.”

Pinsent Masons says that taxpayers with undisclosed liabilities should come forward voluntarily, under professional guidance. For many taxpayers with tax problems, particularly serious ones, the Liechtenstein Disclosure Facility (LDF) will offer the most favourable terms.

Phil Berwick adds: “HMRC is augmenting its arsenal all the time. Individuals with undeclared liabilities should approach the Revenue before they are contacted by the taxman. In particular, they should consider making an unprompted disclosure under the LDF. With the risk of punitive fines and imprisonment growing, a potential 10% penalty through the LDF is looking increasingly attractive.”

Latest press releases

Show me all press releases

Pinsent Masons has 2040 science-based net-zero target verified

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons is one of the first law firms to have its global 2040 net-zero target verified by the Science Based Targets initiative, as it doubles down on efforts to reduce its impact on climate change.

Pinsent Masons is successful with City of Munich landmark Oktoberfest appeal

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons is advising the City of Munich in appeal proceedings brought by the organisers of a planned Oktoberfest event in Dubai. The organisers provided cease-and-desist undertakings, thereby in effect accepting a preliminary injunction issued in this landmark case by the District Court in favour of the City of Munich.

Pinsent Masons advises Northern Gritstone on £215m fund raising

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has advised the new investment business Northern Gritstone, founded by the Universities of Leeds, Manchester and Sheffield, on its £215m fund raising.

People who viewed this press release also viewed

Show me all press releases

Pinsent Masons appoints tax expert in Germany

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has appointed Marcus Hierl as tax partner in its Frankfurt office, responding to a growing client demand across Germany for complex tax advice.

Pinsent Masons launches its tax practice in Spain

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has hired Gonzalo Gil Suarez in Madrid to lead the firm’s tax law practice in Spain.

Pinsent Masons advises Bodymed AG on its sale to Nestle Health Science.

The multinational law firm Pinsent Masons advises the holding company of the founder Dr Hardy Walle on the sale of all shares of Bodymed AG to Nestlé Health Science.

For all media enquiries, including arranging an interview with one of our spokespeople, please contact the press office on

+44 (0)20 7418 8199 or 

Location contacts