Government's BIM target unachievable, says Pinsent Masons Survey

06 Feb 2014 | 12:30 pm | 3 min. read

A Pinsent Masons survey into the use of Building Information Modelling (BIM)* in the construction sector found that nearly two-thirds (64%) of construction experts believe that the Government's 2016 target to achieve Level 2 BIM capability on all centrally procured infrastructure projects** is unachievable.

According to the survey, which canvasses the views of experts from 70 organisations across the infrastructure industry, reveals that collaboration is the key to making BIM a success.

The vast majority (94%) of respondents believe that the use of BIM requires a more collaborative approach between the client and construction team, and over a quarter (27%) cite the absence of collaboration as the most significant barrier to achieving Level 2 BIM capability in their organisation.

Chris Hallam, Partner in Pinsent Masons' Projects, Construction and Engineering team, said: "The overriding message from our survey points to greater collaboration if BIM is to be a success. Collaboration is not, however, a new concept for the industry. For over a generation the Government and industry stakeholders have strived to create a utopia of a more collaborative construction industry with some, albeit limited, success.

"The problem is that the majority of construction contracts are not very collaborative. Risk tends to be allocated in a binary manner, with each party incentivised to look after its own interests – rather than the wider interests of a project. Because the parties' interests are rarely aligned, this tends not to create an environment where true collaboration is possible – at least not if things go wrong. BIM, however, by its very nature requires a more collaborative environment."

This sentiment is supported in the survey, as two-thirds (66%) of those surveyed believe that the existing forms of contract used in the industry, and the approaches taken to contracting are not fit for purpose in a BIM enabled world. It is also interesting to note that 69% said that existing construction contracts fail to adequately address the means by which collaborative contracting can be achieved.

Chris said: "This may not make pleasant reading for the publishers of standard form contracts, particularly the NEC and PPC2000 forms which are generally considered to be at the more collaborative end of the spectrum. We believe this is evidence of an industry crying out for a different approach – for contractual arrangements that work in a collaborative environment. Many believe that the 'Alliancing' model – a 'no-fault' based procurement route where parties share in the success or failure of a project is where the industry should be heading. Indeed, several sectors – including rail and utilities – have embraced Alliancing, and we are starting to see other sectors dip their toes in the water."

Chris added: "Technology is driving change in the way we communicate with and connect to each other. Across many sectors of the economy, for example manufacturing, retail and IT, it has created an environment in which widespread sharing of information and know-how is not only possible, but has become the norm. It could be that BIM and associated technological advances are fostering a more connected, communicative and joined-up approach . This could be a catalyst that finally drives the construction sector towards a truly collaborative way of working. If so, it is inevitable that forms of contract will need to change to accommodate new ways of working."

The survey also shows that the top three benefits gained for the construction sector from the use of BIM are: improvement in the design production process of a construction project (63%); risk mitigation in terms of better on-site clash detection and/or health & safety risk deduction (57%) and greater clarity and transparency for clients (46%). The greatest risk with BIM, as viewed by the respondents to the survey, is around information; over half (52%) believe that integrity of information inputted into construction models could be the greatest risk area for their organisation.

Martin Roberts, Partner in Pinsent Masons' Construction Advisory and Disputes Group, said: "The benefits are clear and the construction industry acknowledges that it can achieve better efficiency and transparency on infrastructure projects. It is however inevitable that there will be some concern when adopting different approaches, particularly one which by necessity requires greater collaboration and connectivity between members of the construction team. But the potential benefits that can be gained from BIM should far outweigh the dangers, and in the round will probably operate to reduce the overall risk profile." 

* What is BIM?

“At its simplest level, BIM provides a common environment for all information defining a building, facility or asset together with its common parts and activities. This including building shape, design and construction time, costs, physical performance, logistics and more.” (RICS “What is BIM?”)                                                                                 

The aspiration in the industry is for BIM models to become the primary tools for the whole project team. 

There can be a number of BIM models for a single project. For example, many construction trades (for example structural engineering, M&E and alike) may develop models for their own purposes. A client may mandate the development of a single “combined model” incorporating the data of a number of authored models (for example of the key designers and subcontractors).

**Centrally procured projects?

These are construction projects procured by central government departments, such as the Ministry of Justice and the Ministry of Defence.  It does not include projects procured by local authorities (although the Government via the BIM Task Group is encouraging the use of Level 2 BIM on these projects). Example: Wrexham Prison.   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Latest press releases

Show me all press releases

Pinsent Masons advises on the project financing of the Rabigh Solar PV IPP Project in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has advised the financiers (Japan Bank for International Cooperation, Mizuho Bank and Al Rajhi Banking and Investment Corporation) on the project financing provided to a consortium led by Marubeni Corporation in joint venture with Al Jomaih Energy & Water Company Limited of the 300MW solar power plant to be built and operated in Rabigh, Saudi Arabia.

Pinsent Masons targets transport and mobility market with the appointment of Finance and Projects partner Miguel Nieto in Madrid

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has appointed transport and infrastructure expert Miguel Nieto, as Finance and Projects partner in Madrid where he will focus on the growing transport and mobility market.

Pinsent Masons publishes its 2020 pay gap report

Pay gap reporting highlights the value and importance of our drive to promote diversity and inclusion. This year we have opted to report on our disability pay gap for the first time as we underscore our commitment to belonging and inclusion and strengthen our network groups to encourage and champion change for all of our people.

People who viewed this press release also viewed

Show me all press releases

Pinsent Masons wins Belt and Road Deal of the Year and Overseas Deal of the Year awards at the China Business Law Awards

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has won Belt and Road Deal of the Year and Overseas Deal of the Year awards for the firms work on the Red Sea Tourism Mega Project in Saudi Arabia and Mexico City's Subway Line Construction Project respectively.

Pinsent Masons advises on commercial close of four new dialysis clinics in Uzbekistan

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has advised on the commercial close of four dialysis centres – a pathfinder public private partnership (PPP) implemented in Uzbekistan.

Pinsent Masons appoints infrastructure partner in Perth

Multinational law firm Pinsent Masons has hired infrastructure partner David Ulbrick to its team in the Perth office.

For all media enquiries, including arranging an interview with one of our spokespeople, please contact the press office on

+44 (0)20 7418 8199 or 

Location contacts