14 Sep 2017 | 10:50 am | 1 min. read
International law firm Pinsent Masons has advised University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust (UHB), one of the pre-eminent NHS trusts both nationally and internationally, on its successful bid to obtain Competition and Markets Authority approval for a merger with Heart of England NHS Foundation Trust.
The merger involves the two largest NHS acute trusts in Birmingham, requiring a careful assessment of the substantial benefits which the merger would realise for the surrounding population against any perceived reduction in choice for patients.
Pinsent Masons supported the UHB Executive Team, along with a team of specialist economic advisors at NERA Economic Consulting, to deliver effective submissions to the CMA and secure the support of key stakeholders, particularly NHS Improvement.
Kate Collyer, Deputy Chief Economic Adviser at the CMA and the decision maker in the case, said:
“This is the first time the CMA has cleared an NHS hospital merger on the basis of patient benefits at phase 1 and [this] reflects the quality of the benefits case put forward....The hospitals involved presented clear evidence and a well-reasoned case."
The Pinsent Masons team was led by EU and Competition partner Giles Warrington with support from Associate Tim Riisager. Legal Director Graham Fyfe is continuing to advise UHB on the structural aspects of the merger.
“By avoiding a detailed Phase 2 review, as has been required in other NHS Trust mergers, the parties are in a position to finalise the merger and deliver further, major improvements for their patients sooner. This decision also could have potentially positive implications for the wider NHS as other acute trusts consider their merger options.”
Giles Warrington has previously represented Hanson Quarry Products Europe on the CMA's market investigation into the supply of aggregates and cement, while the wider Pinsent Masons EU and Competition team has acted as lead external counsel to E.ON in relation to the CMA's market investigation of the energy market, and to Clydesdale Bank in relation to the retail banking market investigation. In January the firm re-appointed Alan Davis from Jones Day to leads its EU and Competition team.
Pinsent Masons continues its expansion in Dublin office with Life Sciences and Technology Litigation hire
International law firm Pinsent Masons, has been recognised as one of the best multinational employers for LGBT+ staff in Stonewall's 2019 Top Global Employers index.
International law firm Pinsent Masons has appointed Lloyd Chater as a partner in its Johannesburg office.
International Law Firm Pinsent Masons has advised Redefine International P.L.C., the FTSE 250 income focused UK-REIT, on the sale of the Leopard (German supermarket) Portfolio for EUR 205 million.
International law firm Pinsent Masons has appointed Alan Davis to lead the firm's EU & Competition practice.
International law firm Pinsent Masons has expanded its Dusseldorf office with the appointment of Dr. Anke Empting as Partner.
For all media enquiries, including arranging an interview with one of our spokespeople, please contact the press office on